This site is intended for Healthcare professionals only.
×

BIMS, BUMS, BAMS cannot prescribe allopathic medicines: High Court

BIMS, BUMS, BAMS cannot prescribe allopathic medicines: High Court

Can ISM Practitioners prescribe Allopathy Medicines?

Not any more. The Delhi high court seems to have put an end to the age old debate of whether BUMS, BIMS, BAMS and other practitioners of Indian Systems of Medicine can prescribe allopathic medicines, by concluding that such practitioners cannot practice modern scientific system of medicine.

The petition was filed by Delhi Medical Association under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, filed as a Public Interest Litigation (PIL), inter alia seeks directions for ensuring that no practitioner of Indian System of Medicine or of Homoeopathic Medicine practices in Allopathic System of Medicine including by prescribing Allopathic Medicines. The petition also impugns Section 2(h) of the Delhi Bharatiya Chikitsa Parishad Act, 1998 (DBCP Act) and the Notification No.28-5/2004-Ay. (MM) dated 19th May, 2004 of the respondent no.8 Central Council of Indian Medicine (CCIM) on the basis whereof the practitioners of Indian System of Medicine are said to be claiming to have a right to practice in the Allopathic System of Medicine.

Hearing the arguments of the petitioner as well as the respondents, the hon’be court observed:-

“….that the definition of  “Indian Medicine‟ in the Indian Medicine Act or of “integrated medicine‟ in DBCP Act or the Notification dated 19th May, 2004 of the CCIM cannot be read as entitling those registered in the State register of Indian Medicine maintained by DBCP to practise modern scientific system of medicine in any form regulated by the MCI Act and the DMC Act….”

Should there be a national exit exam for Doctors after MBBS?

 

“….We also do not find any merit in the challenge to the maintainability of this petition as a PIL or on the ground of the same having been filed for any oblique purpose. Rather, we do find the notification dated 19th May, 2004 of the CCIM as set out hereinabove to be quite misleading and capable of being understood as allowing persons not holding qualification in modern scientific system of medicine to practice the said system of medicine and which is contrary to law and can play havoc with the health and lives of citizens of the city. We remind CCIM that it being a creature of the Indian Medicine Act, does not enjoy any legislative or quasi legislative powers and has to confine itself to the field of Indian System of Medicine only and perform duties and functions as prescribed in the said Act and cannot transgress into the field/territory occupied by the MCI Act……”

The hon’ble court thus allowed the petition

 

(A) By declaring that no practitioner of Indian System of Medicine or holding a qualification as listed in the Schedule to the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, even if it be of in integrated medicine as defined in Section 2(h) of the Delhi Bharatiya Chikitsa Parishad Act, 1998, is entitled to practice modern scientific system of medicine as defined in the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 read with Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 and as has come to be known as Allopathic system of medicine.

(B)  By directing all the authorities concerned with enforcement of the provisions of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, Delhi Medical Council Act, 1997, Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 and the Delhi Bharatiya Chikitsa Parishad Act, 1998 and/or entrusted with the task of preventing persons not holding qualification as mentioned in the Schedules of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 from practicing modern scientific system of medicine, to not allow any person holding qualification in Indian Medicine as described in the Schedule to the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, even if holding a degree in integrated course as defined in the Delhi Bharatiya Chikitsa Parishad Act, 1998, from practicing modern scientific system of medicine.

(C)  By declaring that Section 2(h) of the Delhi Bharatiya Chikitsa Parishad Act, 1998 or any other provision thereof or of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 does not permit any person holding qualification in Indian Medicine as prescribed in the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970 even if a degree in integrated course to practice modern scientific system of medicine in terms of Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 read with Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916 and Delhi Medical Council Act, 1997.

(D)  By declaring that the Notification dated 10th February, 1961 of the Delhi Government issued in pursuance to Rule 2(ee) of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945 does not entitle any person not holding a qualification listed in the Schedules to the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and whose name is not entered in the State Medical Register under the Delhi Medical Council Act, 1997 to prescribe Allopathic drugs.

(E)  By declaring that the Notification dated 19th May, 2004 of the Central Council of Indian Medicine does not entitle the practitioners of Indian Medicine within the meaning of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, even if holding degree in integrated medicine within the meaning of the Delhi Bharatiya Chikitsa Parishad Act, 1998 to practice modern scientific system of medicine / Allopathic system of medicine within the meaning of Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 read with Indian Medical Degrees Act, 1916.

You can read the full judgement here

Source: self
135 comment(s) on BIMS, BUMS, BAMS cannot prescribe allopathic medicines: High Court

Share your Opinion Disclaimer

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Most Voted
  1. Indian system of medicines named as Ayush is an amalgam of traditional systems of medicines , and Allopathic system is the scientific system of medicine. Only the doctors trained in allopathic have a right to practice this system .

  2. user
    Dr.NAGENDRA.P.N MYSORE January 7, 2017, 2:22 pm

    This copy must be sent to all those quacks who think they can practice our system of medicine .I recently saw a message being circulated which says ayush ppl have gained permission to practice allopayhy by taking 6m training

  3. Dr.A k,

    Hi all dispensaries,

    Why u people are quarrelling
    Just overlook my fight with dr. Reddy he is a true professional guy .

    Don\’t pull undergarments.

  4. user
    Dr.RAKESH KUMAR KAPOOR December 24, 2016, 1:10 pm

    Dear Friends,
    I would like to request THE EDITORIAL BOARD TO PLEASE ASK ALL THE MEMBERS OF DOCPLEXUS TO PROVIDE THE PROOF OF M.B.B.S.DEGREE and only then allow us to be continuing as MEMBERS .THOSE BOGUS ALLOPATHIC PRACTITIONERS OF ALLOPATHIC MEDICINES TO BE DELETED FROM OUR DOCPLEXUS.THEY ONLY VITIATE THE ATMOSPHERE but REFLECT THEIR FRUSTRATION IN VARIOUS WAYS FROM TIME TO TIME.Dr.Rakesh Kumar Kapoor

  5. user
    Dr.RAKESH KUMAR KAPOOR December 24, 2016, 1:01 pm

    Dear Dr.Praveen Kumar Namaskar. Why you got so much DISTURBED BY A FAIR JUDGEMENT .I hope you are not amongst us(M.B.B.S.)DOCTORS.I would like to know about your EXACT QUALIFICATIONS.The very fact that you are not a QUALIFIED ALLOPATHIC DOCTOR IS REFLECTED BY YOUR REACTION.I or YOu need not to GUIDE PEOPLE about what to do.Our fellow countrymen are having enough wisdom to treat well to the TRESSPASSERS OF THEIR LIMITS IN TREATING THE PATIENTS BY ALLOPATHIC DRUGS UNAUTHRISEDLY.The days of such SO CALLED ALLOPATHIC MEDICINE PRESCRIBERS ARE NUMBERED .Dr.RAKESH KUMAR KAPOOR

  6. Rakesh sir you cant run from crosstalking because people doesnt need degree they require faith in doctor for recovery within budget.some our people contineously harrasing patient from specialist to specialist without using clinical knowledge.we treat only lab reports not patient its fact.neurologist doesnt see gastritis patient,gastroenterologist doesnt see headache patient,physician doesnt see tonsillitis patient,ortopaedician doesnt see rheumstology patient.its very irritating to common man to wander here and there.superspeciality and corporate hospitals snatching lacs and lacs from simple cases.readDESENTING DIAGNOSIS BOOK BY DR.ARUN GADRE,M.D.GYNAEC.poori lag nikali hai apne profession ki,specialists,cut practice,lab reports,corporate hospital strategies.rakesh sir these people really satisfies patient,we have to change ourselves because patient knows their address of recovery.

  7. dear rakesh sir you get very angry soon,its not good for your profession and for your opd otherwise you have to play rummy in your opd with your compounders.for your information i am mbbs but my last generation is BAMS.if you reach 5%of their devotion without subject of money and glamour them i will salute you sir.they really stolen your sorry (our)bread and butter.But you cant do anything AS (1)peoples in politics have at least 1BAMS OR BHMS college per 3MPS andMLAS.if they allow this act to pass then their DUKANDARI will stop as they accept approx.15lac perBAMS student for the course.So dont take tension rakeshbhai it never happen.so be cool and calm.take care of your patients.another thing is our people never go to villages except PHCtraining as we have to spend more money on our Pg degree.Again one thing is that our mbbs storm from foreign countries were coming to take our tea and coffee also as govt.allow them to practice without mci entrance,so be prepare ,care for patients so they cant leave you.by my previous generations blessings i have 150+opd per day as i am in a village boy doing good job for my patients,thanks sirji.