Patna: In a recent ruling, the Patna High Court observed that mere dissimilarity between signatures appearing on the admit card and OMR answer sheet of a candidate does not establish tampering of the OMR sheet, especially when the examination authority produces the original OMR records, and there is no other convincing evidence of such tampering or manipulation.

With this observation, the Patna HC bench of Justice Harish Kumar dismissed a batch of petitions filed under Article 226 of the Constitution by NEET-UG 2026 aspirants who challenged the marks secured in the exam and also the OMR sheets maintained by the National Testing Agency (NTA), which conducted the undergraduate medical entrance test.

"This Court also finds that heavy reliance has been placed upon the dissimilarity between the signatures appearing on the petitioners' provisional admit cards and those appearing on the OMR answer sheets provided to them and secured on the website. Upon perusal of the signatures of the petitioners found on the admit cards as well as the OMR sheets, and comparison thereof with the signatures found on the affidavits as well as Vakalatnamas, this Court finds that the signatures are not thoroughly identical," observed the HC bench.

"Such dissimilarity between signatures appearing on different documents executed at different points of time, by itself, cannot be considered sufficient to hold that the OMR answer sheets had been tampered with. It is well founded and relevant to note that the handwriting and signatures of any person are subject to inherent variations. The physical and emotional state of a person at the time of subscribing a signature may also contribute to such variations. The state of mind of candidates at the time of subscribing their signatures in the examination room may, in the ordinary course, be different from that prevailing at the time of signing an admit card or other documents. Therefore, such variations in signatures, by themselves, cannot constitute a ground to contend that the OMR answer sheets had been tampered with or swapped, as sought to be contended by the learned Advocates for the petitioners," it further noted.

Case Background: 

The petitioners before the High Court are students aspiring to pursue the MBBS course. They appeared in the National Eligibility-Entrance Test Undergraduate (NEET-UG) 2026 examination conducted by the NTA. The Court noted that their grievances were similar.

In one petition, the candidate claimed that she had secured 622 marks out of 720 marks and obtained a rank of 2500 under GEN-EWS. However, after applying the percentile formula, her percentile score was declared as 11.2376900 and her marks were allegedly reduced to 81 out of 720 and her category rank downgraded to 143568. Due to this, she was not shortlisted for any of the Government Medical Colleges. Filing the plea before the High Court, the petitioner sought recalculation/reverification of her percentile marks and production of her original OMR and answer sheet.

In another connected matter, the petitioner claimed alteration of her OMR sheet during evaluation. The petitioner alleged that she had attempted 169 out of 180 questions and expected to secure around 560 marks. However, after the OMR was uploaded on the NTA website, she found that the marks had allegedly been awarded for only 33 questions.

She sought production of the original as well as the carbon copy of her OMR sheet, and if her contention is found to be correct, she sought appropriate action to be declared a successful candidate in NEET UG 2026.

In another plea, the grievance of the petitioner is that the result was declared on 16.07.2026 and, on 17.07.2026 at 00:55:49, when the result of the petitioner was accessed, it was found on the official portal of the NTA that she had obtained 611 marks with NEET All India Rank 79459 and Category Rank 5532. However, immediately thereafter, the result was allegedly altered on the official portal and the marks were reduced to 194, with NEET All India Rank 1098925 and Category Rank 472325.

The petitioner in this case sought quashing of the altered result dated 17.07.2026, duly downloaded at 10:51:18 and a direction to the respondents to re-verify the petitioner's NEET-UG 2026 result and restore the correct marks, rank and category rank.

Observations by HC bench: 

While considering these petitions, the HC bench observed that all the petitioners alleged that their scorecards initially reflected substantially higher marks which were reduced later. They also expressed doubts regarding the genuineness of the OMR sheets and alleged the possibility of OMR replacement or alteration.

Taking note of the fact that all the petitioners were young NEET aspirants whose academic careers were at stake, the HC bench directed the NTA on 17.08.2026 to produce the original OMR sheets. Following this, NTA produced the original OMR sheets in sealed envelopes on 27.08.2026.

Upon opening the sealed envelopes, the respective OMR sheets were shown to the petitioners along with their Advocates. After perusing the respective OMR sheets, the petitioners categorically stated that the OMR sheets/answer sheets produced did not belong to them and had never been filled up by them. All the petitioners categorically disputed the genuineness of the said OMR answer sheets and stated that the signatures appearing thereon were not their signatures.

Before adjudicating the facts of the case, the Court observed that a national entrance examination is undoubtedly a trust-based administrative exercise, as lakhs and lakhs of students, after devoting their day and night for years, appear in the examination on the assumption that the system will preserve their answers accurately, evaluate them in accordance with predetermined rules and publish the scorecards fairly.

"However, when such a system is questioned, transparency becomes indispensable. The litigation may, therefore, have significance beyond the fate of an individual candidate. In such circumstances, the examination authorities are bound to demonstrate robust preservation of physical and electronic records so as to encourage stronger protocols for OMR custody, scanning, database controls, auditability and dispute resolution," it further observed.

The Court noted that the dispute in such cases may not necessarily be whether the candidates actually scored higher marks as claimed or otherwise, but whether the examination authority is able to satisfy the Court by producing a credible, continuous and verifiable evidentiary trail connecting the candidates who entered the examination hall, the OMR sheets allegedly filled by them, the digital images generated therefrom, the marks calculated on the basis thereof, and the scores ultimately published.

"...it is true that the petitioners are aspiring to pursue MBBS courses and that the result of NEET-UG 2026 is of considerable importance to their academic careers. This Court is also conscious that even small differences in marks may have a substantial bearing upon the prospects of a candidate in a highly competitive examination. At the same time, however, mere sympathy or possible academic consequences of the result cannot constitute a ground for directing alteration of an examination record which has been produced in original and found to contain the responses on the basis of which the petitioners have been evaluated. This Court is also conscious of the judicial restraint required to balance the individual grievance of a candidate with the larger requirement of maintaining the sanctity, uniformity and finality of the competitive examination process," the bench further observed.

After a careful consideration of the original OMR sheets, the Court found that they contained roll number, test booklet number, answer sheet number and OMR code along with name, signature, and thumb impression of the petitioners. The OMR also contained the name of parents as well as signature of invigilator and the answer attempted by the petitioners, which have been duly scanned and evaluated in a secure environment at NTA headquarters.

The Court noted that only one petitioner challenged the OMR answer sheet during the stipulated period from 13.07.2026 to 15.07.2026. However, out of the three petitioners, two of them have not even challenged the same. It is also not the case of the petitioners that they had at any time downloaded the OMR, which was found to their satisfaction, as asserted in the writ petition, which would have the clinching effect, noted the Court.

On the other hand, it was the case of the NTA that as per the calculation sheet of the marks prepared on the basis of the performance/answers as also after publication of the final answer key, the petitioners had been correctly awarded the respective marks and the rank.

"This Court also finds that the scanning of the QR code on the scorecard enclosed by the petitioners upon which they are placing reliance does not bring to them the scorecard issued by the NTA, whereas the scorecards which are said to have been issued by the NTA take the petitioners to the original scorecard," further noted the Court.

The bench also took note of the letter issued by the NIC dated 25.08.2026, which has also been brought on record in the counter affidavit. The letter clearly certified that only one OMR answer sheet was uploaded in respect of the petitioners on NIC server and there is no change to the OMR as on date. The certificates issued by the NIC also prescribe the date on which the actual results have been uploaded, which also finds differences in the date and time of the scorecard brought on record by the petitioners.

Taking note of this, the HC bench observed, "In such circumstances, the contention of the petitioners that the scorecard upon which they are placing reliance were downloaded from the website of NTA does not corroborate it, since the scorecard issued by the website of NTA has a unique QR code which, upon scanning, is brought to the original scorecard. This fact also requires attention, that in no possibility two candidates can have same rank having different scores, as it has been shown to us by the learned Advocate for the NTA."

Referring to the contention regarding dissimilarity between the signatures, the HC bench observed that merely such dissimilarity between signatures appearing on different documents executed at different points of time, by itself, cannot be considered sufficient to hold that the OMR answer sheets had been tampered with.

"The petitioners have not ascribed any ill-will or mala fide intention to any officiating staff of the examination room to the effect that they might have tampered with or swapped the OMR sheets filled by the petitioners with the disputed OMR sheets with a view to prevent them from qualifying in the examination," observed the Court.

"The National Testing Agency conducts the NEETUG Examination on a national scale through a standardized process. Judicial interference with the evaluation process based solely upon an individual's apprehension, unsupported by convincing evidence, would adversely affect the certainty, sanctity and finality of the examination system. Merely because, by an interim order, a candidate may have been permitted to participate in counselling, subject to the final enquiry or outcome of the case on the peculiar facts and circumstances of that case, such an order does not constitute a binding precedent. Moreover, in the present cases, the petitioners have failed to establish any arbitrariness, illegality, mala fides or procedural irregularity on the part of the respondent authorities in the evaluation of their answer sheets. This Court has also perused the original OMR sheets of all the candidates and compared the signatures of the petitioners with the signatures appearing on the attendance sheets, Vakalatnamas and affidavits and found some variation. However, as this Court has rightly observed in the foregoing paragraphs, the signatures of any candidate or person are subject to inherent variations, and such variation in signatures appearing on some documents, by itself, cannot constitute a ground to contend that the OMR sheets had been tampered with or swapped, as sought to be contended by the learned Advocates for the petitioners," it further noted.

"If the petitioners still dispute the genuineness of the OMR sheets duly produced before this Court, in such circumstances, this Court is of the opinion that the disputed questions of fact are required to be adjudicated upon by a competent Civil Court, requiring elaborate examination of witnesses and documentary evidence to establish the respective claims," held the HC bench.

Accordingly, finding no illegality or infirmity on the part of NTA and no sufficient basis to doubt the records maintained by the NTA, the Court dismissed the petitions.

To view the order, click on the link below:

https://medicaldialogues.in/pdf_upload/2026/10/08/-vs-uoi-478768.pdf

Also Read: NEET OMR Sheet Tampering Allegations Need Credible Evidence, Rules Chhattisgarh HC

Tags:    

Disclaimer: This website is primarily for healthcare professionals. The content here does not replace medical advice and should not be used as medical, diagnostic, endorsement, treatment, or prescription advice. Medical science evolves rapidly, and we strive to keep our information current. If you find any discrepancies, please contact us at corrections@medicaldialogues.in. Read our Correction Policy here. Nothing here should be used as a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. We do not endorse any healthcare advice that contradicts a physician's guidance. Use of this site is subject to our Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and Advertisement Policy. For more details, read our Full Disclaimer here.

NOTE: Join us in combating medical misinformation. If you encounter a questionable health, medical, or medical education claim, email us at factcheck@medicaldialogues.in for evaluation.

Our comments section is governed by our Comments Policy . By posting comments at Medical Dialogues you automatically agree with our Comments Policy , Terms And Conditions and Privacy Policy .