Consumer court dismisses medical negligence, fraud complaint against Mohali's hospital, urologist over alleged unperformed surgery
Mohali: Rejecting allegations that a private hospital and its urologist had charged a patient for a prostate-related surgical procedure without actually performing it, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, SAS Nagar (Mohali), dismissed a medical negligence and fraud complaint.
The Commission observed that the hospital's discharge summary, operative notes, consent forms and other medical records supported its claim that the surgery had been performed. It further held that the persistence of urinary symptoms following treatment did not, by itself, establish medical negligence.
The matter concerned a patient who initially visited the Urology Department of PGI Chandigarh on June 27, 2021, after developing acute urinary retention. A catheter was inserted, and he was advised to have it removed within 15 days to avoid infection and other complications.
The patient subsequently approached Shalby Multi-Specialty Hospital in Mohali for catheter removal.
According to the complaint, after removing the catheter and conducting an X-ray examination, the hospital informed him that his urinary passage was abnormally curved and that his prostate gland required immediate surgical intervention.
The patient alleged that the hospital and the treating doctor created fear in his mind and collected Rs 76,170 towards surgery and related expenses, although no operation was actually performed.
He further claimed that he had experienced no pain during the alleged operation and that an investigation conducted at another diagnostic centre supported his suspicion that surgery had not been carried out.
Maintaining that his urinary problems persisted despite the alleged procedure, the patient accused the hospital and doctor of medical negligence, fraud and deficiency in service.
He sought a refund of Rs 76,170 with 18% annual interest, Rs 5 lakh as compensation, Rs 50,000 for mental agony and harassment, Rs 50,000 towards medical expenses and Rs 25,000 as litigation costs.
Contesting the allegations, the hospital and the treating urologist maintained that the patient had undergone the necessary surgical procedures following appropriate investigations and informed consent.
They submitted that the patient returned to the hospital on July 26, 2021, complaining of difficulty in passing urine and a very thin urinary stream.
A uroflowmetry examination revealed an obstructive pattern, following which a retrograde urethrogram was advised. The investigation showed an irregular outline and abnormal calibre of the posterior urethra.
According to the hospital, the findings were explained to the patient and his daughter, and the necessary pre-operative investigations and consent formalities were completed.
The hospital maintained that the patient underwent cystoscopy, optical internal urethrotomy (OIU), bladder neck incision (BNI) and resection of prostate chips under general anaesthesia.
It further submitted that the patient had not disclosed a previous prostate surgery during the initial assessment, which was relevant to his treatment.
The hospital relied on the discharge summary, operative notes, anaesthesia records, consent forms, surgical safety checklist, diagnostic reports and post-operative records to establish that the procedures had been performed.
After examining the evidence, the Consumer Commission noted that the patient's investigations had provided a clinical basis for further evaluation and surgical intervention.
The Commission specifically referred to the discharge summary dated August 19, 2021, which recorded a diagnosis of urethral stricture with bladder neck contraction and documented that OIU, BNI and resection of prostate chips had been performed under general anaesthesia.
The Commission also examined the ultrasound report dated August 26, 2021, which the complainant had relied upon to support his allegation that no surgery had been performed. The report recorded that no significant retained prostatic contents were seen and that the post-void residual urine volume was only 10 cc.
However, the Commission held that these findings did not establish that surgery had never been performed.
It observed that the ultrasound findings had to be considered alongside the discharge summary and operative records, which provided substantial support for the hospital's defence.
Addressing the complainant's argument that his urinary problems had continued after surgery, the Commission observed:
"The persistence of certain symptoms following surgery does not, by itself, establish medical negligence."
Referring to the Supreme Court's decision in S.K. Jhunjhunwala v. Dhanwanti Kaur and Another, the Commission reiterated that the continuation of an ailment following medical treatment does not automatically establish negligence. It noted that evidence must demonstrate a connection between the alleged negligent act and the harm suffered, and that the clinical circumstances and medical records must be examined together.
The Commission also clarified that the hospital's allegation that the patient had concealed his previous prostate surgery could not independently determine the outcome of the complaint.
Similarly, the hospital's alleged failure to respond to the patient's legal notice was not sufficient to establish medical negligence or fraud.
Finding that the allegation of collecting Rs 76,170 without performing surgery was not substantiated by the evidence, the Commission dismissed the complaint.
In its final order, the Commission stated:
"Consequently, keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, the present complaint fails and is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs."
Also Read:Urine test may improve bladder cancer diagnosis and guide treatment decisions: Study
Disclaimer: This website is primarily for healthcare professionals. The content here does not replace medical advice and should not be used as medical, diagnostic, endorsement, treatment, or prescription advice. Medical science evolves rapidly, and we strive to keep our information current. If you find any discrepancies, please contact us at corrections@medicaldialogues.in. Read our Correction Policy here. Nothing here should be used as a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. We do not endorse any healthcare advice that contradicts a physician's guidance. Use of this site is subject to our Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, and Advertisement Policy. For more details, read our Full Disclaimer here.
NOTE: Join us in combating medical misinformation. If you encounter a questionable health, medical, or medical education claim, email us at factcheck@medicaldialogues.in for evaluation.