Burnaid hydrogel dressing not superior to PVC Flim for acute burns in kids

Over the past decade, Burnaid hydrogel dressings have gained widespread use in the prehospital setting for acute burn injuries—and are promoted as providing hydration to the burn wound and pain relief via convection and evaporative cooling effect. PVC film offers protection from the external environment, Burnaid dressings provide evaporative cooling and a significant reduction in subdermal temperatures when air currents pass over the dressing. Despite the popularity among prehospital services, there is limited empirical evidence for the effectiveness of hydrogel burn dressings and no studies have been conducted in a paediatric burn population. At present, there is no robust empirical evidence to support the adoption of one particular acute burn dressing over the others. Therefore, investigators of Australia, conducted a study, to compare the effectiveness of two acute burn dressings, Burnaid hydrogel dressing and plasticised polyvinylchloride film, on reducing acute pain scores in paediatric burn patients following appropriate first aid.

It was a single-centre, superiority, two-arm, parallel-group, prospective randomised controlled trial in 72 pediatric patients presenting to the Emergency Department at the Queensland Children's Hospital, Brisbane, Australia with an acute thermal burn between September 2017 and September 2018. Investigators assigned the patients to receive either Burnaid hydrogel dressing (intervention n=37) or plasticised polyvinylchloride film (Control n=35) as an acute burn dressing. The major outcome assessed was observational pain scores from nursing staff assessed 5 min post-application of the randomised dressing, measured using the Face Legs Activity Cry and Consolability Scale. Repeated measures of pain, stress and re-epithelialisation were also collected at follow-up dressing changes until 95% wound re-epithelialisation occurred.

Upon evaluation, investigators identified no significant between-group differences in nursing (mean difference: −0.1) or caregiver (MD: 1) in observational pain scores. They also found no significant differences in child self-report pain (MD: 0.3), heart rate (MD: −3), temperature (MD: 0.6), stress (geometric mean ratio: 1.53), or re-epithelialisation rates (MD: −1) between the two groups.

The authors concluded, "A clear benefit of Burnaid hydrogel dressing as an analgesic adjunct to first aid for the treatment of acute paediatric burns was not identified in this investigation".

For further information:

https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/11/1/e039981