Electroconvulsive therapy safe for treatment of mental conditions, suggests large-scale study

Unlike its depiction in non-scientific media or films, ECT is performed under short-term anesthesia and the medical team induces a single brief epileptic seizure during the treatment session. The technology uses a carefully controlled electrical current that causes a discharge of nerve impulses in the brain while leaving the rest of the body unaffected. This is thought to function as a 'reset' for the brain functions underlying several mental conditions.

The current study is a retrospective analysis that looked at the safety protocols and medical records of 157 patients who, combined, received more than 3,100 ECT sessions during the three years between 2018 and 2020. Across this data set, there were only three patients who experienced potentially life-threatening complications, but all three recovered with no lasting effects. Less than 20% of patients reported milder adverse events, such as cognitive or cerebral disturbances. These minor effects were largely associated with higher doses of electrical stimulus and increased number of treatment sessions.

ECT is safe but should be done in maximally controlled settings

One of the most important caveats of this work is the potential variation between ECT procedures in different hospitals and countries. The authors emphasize that ECT should only be performed in a controlled setting by an experienced medical team including a physician, nurse, and anesthetist, and that there should be access to intensive care methods if an emergency arises. To account for procedural variations, the authors recommend that each institution compile their own safety data and risk profile.

"We hope that our data will bring the discussion about ECT to a more factual level because the low risk profile of ECT suggests that broader use could benefit many more patients," concluded Hajak.