Does Toupet fundoplication provide better outcome after para-esophageal hernia repair?

Between May 2009 and October 2018, a randomized, double-blind clinical experiment was undertaken. After hernia reduction and crural repair, a total of 70 patients with symptomatic POH were assigned to either a whole (Nissen) or a posterior partial (Toupet) fundoplication. At six months after surgery, dysphagia (measured by Ogilvie dysphagia scores) was the main result. The Dakkak dysphagia score, quality of life (QoL), peri- and postoperative problems, gastroesophageal reflux, peri- and postoperative complications, and radiologically verified hernia recurrence were secondary outcomes.

The key findings of this study were as follows:

1. Ogilvie dysphagia ratings were constant in the Nissen group at the 3- and 6-month follow-ups compared to baseline, but considerably better in the Toupet group.

2. At six months, the Nissen group had substantially higher Dakkak dysphagia scores than the Toupet group.

3. The absolute median improvement from preoperative values in the mental component scores of the Short Form-36 Quality - of - life questionnaire was, however, considerably larger in the Toupet group at 3 and 6 months postoperatively.

4. At 6 months, POH recurrence was radiologically verified in 15 of 32 patients (47%) in the Toupet group and 11 of 24 patients (47%) in the Nissen group.

In conclusion, from the findings of this study, it is advisable to employ partial posterior wrap (Toupet fundoplication) after para-oesophageal hernia repair for better and efficient prognosis.

Reference: 

Analatos, A., Lindblad, M., Ansorge, C., Lundell, L., Thorell, A., & Håkanson, B. S. (2022). Total versus partial posterior fundoplication in the surgical repair of para-oesophageal hernias: randomized clinical trial. In BJS Open (Vol. 6, Issue 3). https://doi.org/10.1093/bjsopen/zrac034