This site is intended for Healthcare professionals only.
×

DNB will be Equivalent to MD in ALL Respects: Health Ministry Clarifies on NMC Bill


DNB will be Equivalent to MD in ALL Respects: Health Ministry Clarifies on NMC Bill

New Delhi: Bringing a sense of respite to the DNB candidates across the country, the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has clarified that in the impending National Medical Commission, DNB qualifications of candidates who have done their course from 500 bedded hospitals will be considered equivalent to PG/SS qualifications in all respects.

Earlier, this was limited to only those DNB degrees, whereby candidate had passed from MCI recognised institutions , that is medical colleges.

The clarification came in response to the query raised by Association of National Board Accredited Institutions ( ANBAI), the umbrella body of Hospitals providing DNB courses across the country, whereby Under Secretary ( Health)  to the Govermentt of India cleared the air about the status of MD-DNB Equivalence within the ambit of the impending National Medical Commission Bill.

The reply sent to Dr Alexander Thomas by the Undersecretary Health, Shri Amit Biswas stated

I am directed to refer to your letter dated 29.03.2018 on the subject cited above and to say that the clause with regard to equivalence of DNB with other PG / SS qualifications under the National Medical Commission Bill, 2017 as introduced in the Lok Sabha has been amended after considering the recommendations of the Department – related Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health & Family Welfare made in its 109°’ Report. In terms of the said Bill, the DNB degree shall be equivalent to other PG / SS qualifications in all respects including for the purpose of teaching.

The letter went on to clarify that as per the Amended clause in the NMC Bill, for those candidates who have completed their DNB from medical institutions attached with hospitals (aka medical colleges) as well as 500+bedded hospitals, their degree shall be considered equivalent to PG/SS qualifications in all respects . Others will have to do 1 year SRship

 The amended clause of the NMC Bill, 2017 prescribes that the DNB qualifications when granted in a medical institution with attached hospital or in hospital with at least 500 beds, shall be equivalent in all respect to the corresponding PG/SS qualification and in all other cases, senior residency in a medical college for an additional period of one year shall be required for such qualification to be equivalent.

Medical Dialogues had earlier reported that DNB candidates were extremely disappointed after the parliamentary committee on health which was deciding on the amendments of the National Medical Commission bill had stated that with the bill,DNB qualification which is awarded by NBE shall be equal in all respects to the post-graduate qualification and the super-specialty qualification, respectively, as granted under this Act with the exception in teaching in medical colleges as they do not take DNB education in a medical college

Read also: DNB equivalent to MD, but not in Teaching: Parliamentary panel on NMC Bill

Demanding equivalence for NBE qualifications, ANBAI held a meeting first with the PMO and then with the Health Ministry, asking then to establish equivalence.

Speaking to Medical Dialogues team, Dr Alexander Thomas, President ANBAI, whose letter finally led to the above health ministry clarification stated,” The 2012 GOI gazette notification, specifies DNB equivalence to MD for all those candidates who have undergone DNB training in an institution which now runs MCI recognized postgraduate degree courses in a given subject as well as those who have undergone training in multi-specialty teaching hospital with at least 500 beds that meet certain criteria laid . For the remaining, the notification called for one additional year of senior residency or equivalent training or research job in an MCI recognized hospital/institution, for the purposes of equivalence.”

“This notification was, however, overturned when in 2017, MCI took out another gazette notification that implied DNB equivalence for only those candidates who have undergone training in an institution which runs MCI recognized postgraduate degree courses.” he explained

” We are happy that the government has decided to re-instate the equivalence in the upcoming National Medical Commission Bill,” Dr Alex added

Read Also: ANBAI officials Meet Health Ministry: Nadda Assures MD-DNB equivalence




Source: self
26 comment(s) on DNB will be Equivalent to MD in ALL Respects: Health Ministry Clarifies on NMC Bill

Share your Opinion Disclaimer

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Most Voted
  1. as there is no age limit for sr when we entered for pg course in2015.now in2017 there is age for sr.there should be age relaxation at least for2015 entry batch otherwise it will be cheating with themk

  2. What about diplomas holders???Ok if not teaching faculty why are they discriminated against?? I felt in India you can\’t discriminate against anybody on any basis but government as well as corporates are discriminating against diploma holders….Why ?Why then to keep such courses in any medical college at first place …Please stop diploma courses in colleges instead keep a few more MD or Dnb seats so that nobody is discriminated against and skills are used at least at some level

  3. All these problems can be solved if we had common post-graduation courses instead of too many courses for the same broad/super speciality course.

  4. The way medical education UG PG DNB is treated admitted conducted in India is v v v illogical n ridiculous..for dat matter all exams in every education system..whether school college or any graduation…theres no job guarantee..&actually no development work in govt or private …just a hype created on maybe/if/but basis to ensure ez salaries of professors teachers…the assignments exams n 75%attendance all4 salary protection..vivas n exam expectations r skytouching wd nothing at end of road unless one does smthing by ones ownself…after so much hardwork it is indeed atrocious to label n brand the DNB doctor as not equivalent to MD if s/he is 4m certain hospital/college..lets wait for laws of nature &karma to take toll on life of such law makers n govts…thats all a helpless DNB can do..&even the UGneet student wishing to study abroad or in India can do…maybe risingislamic populations will do more justice to Indians than Indians themselves…or at least such situations education laws will be finished altogether..I think our MCI Dmers Dnb &such regulatory bodies aicte hrdministry eduministry is waiting4dat day..till then they r sure about their invincibility n peoples vulnerability… its a sad situation…v sick n unfortunate to b born here as a gifted intelligent aspiring soul

  5. ANBAI has backstabbed DNBs. Who is ANBAI to ask for 1 year clause. Where is NBE. Why it\’s officials so silent.
    It\’s a shame

  6. The One year Clause for smaller hospitals was already there in the 2012 notification. It was the MCI that changed it to 3 years on its own whim…i hope the MCI goes soon and NMC comes