This site is intended for Healthcare professionals only.

Doctor Declared Quack by IMA, gets relief from court against 5 year Jail

Doctor Declared Quack by IMA, gets relief from court against 5 year Jail

Dehradun: Reversing the decision of Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) in Dehradun that pronounced 5 years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of 21,000 on a quack who had been practicing in the area, claiming himself to be an epilepsy expert, the Additional District Judge Vinod Kumar has acquitted Rajesh Kumar Gupta against the charges of using banned drugs for treating epilepsy patients.

Medical Dialogues had earlier reported about Rajesh Kumar Gupta, who ran Neeraj Clinic in Rishikesh, and was indeed one of the popular  “doctors”  in the area. He had numerous pictures with prominent people and heavily advertised practice, including daily articles that aimed to prove him as an Epilepsy Expert. However, he did not escape the wrath of the local Indian Medical Association branch, who took cognizance of his extravagant advertisements, investigated his claim, only to finally declare him as a quack in the year 2000.

Read also: Court pronounces 5-year jail-time, Rs 21,000 fine for a Quack

Despite all odds, the man continued to practice only to be brought under the radar in 2014 after a Canadian patient of his, complained to the state government that he was ‘dubious’ and was allegedly giving medicines laced with sedatives.

Finally, he was later arrested and the CJM found him guilty under section 224 (resistance or obstruction by a person to his lawful apprehension), section 420 (cheating) of IPC and section 7 of The Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Act 1954. The CJM sentenced him to 5 years imprisonment and imposed a Rs 21,000 fine on him a month back

However, Gupta filed an appeal against the decision of CJM in the court of Additional District Judge Vinod Kumar, who is also special judge Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act cases. Judge Vinod Kumar found the claims made by witnesses against Gupta were inappropriate and thus released him.

Defence lawyer Rupesh Bhandari told TOI, “We had appealed against the CJM court order before the appellate court on December 21. The prosecution failed to prove the charges and court found that the available evidence were not enough to hold him guilty.”

Further, the court of Additional District Judge also acquitted 14 others, who were allegedly accused for helping Dr Gupta flee from police custody in 2004 reports Tribune 

Source: with inputs
3 comment(s) on Doctor Declared Quack by IMA, gets relief from court against 5 year Jail

Share your Opinion Disclaimer

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Most Voted
  1. Since, IMA has not furnished enough evidence and documents to prove the accused Doctor RK Gupta as quack, he was acquitted. He was charged with Sec 224 and 420 of IPC and sec 7 of drug and magic remedies act and not under state act of unauthorized practice of Medicine to be called as quack. A quack is defined as \”untrained person who pretends to be a physician and dispenses medical advice and treatment\”

  2. This happens only in india

  3. Nothing is mentioned about medical qualifications of the accused doctor and on which merit he was practising as \”Epilepsy Expert\”. Of course, In our country, only qualified doctors are harassed for one or other reason by media, court of law and lay man. Quacks can get away with everything with right contact and right amount of money thrown at right places…Same case with so called \”miracle babas\”. Mera Bharat Mahan…!!!