Probiotics beneficial for newborns with very low birth weight but fail to prevent sepsis, mortality: JAMA
USA: A study of 307,000 neonates with very low birth weights showed a slow increase in adopting routine probiotics from 2012 to 2019 in neonatal ICUs, which was linked to lower risk of necrotizing enterocolitis but not mortality rates or sepsis. The findings were published in JAMA Health Forum on May 12, 2023.
The study revealed that from 807 NICUs (neonatal intensive care units) studied, 17% had adopted routine probiotics use by 2019. There was a decline in necrotizing enterocolitis by 18% at adopting NICUs versus nonadopting NICUs, and probiotic adoption was not tied to significant changes in sepsis or mortality.
RCTs (Randomized clinical trials) indicate that probiotic treatment reduces the risk of necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) for neonates with very low birth weight (VLBW), with smaller decreases in the risk of death and sepsis. There needs to be more evidence on the rate of probiotic adoption in US NICUs and whether the benefits seen in the trial have been brought to practice.
Leila Agha, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, and colleagues aimed to estimate changes in probiotic use in neonates with very low birth weight to fill this knowledge gap. They also tested whether neonates with VLBW treated at NICUs adopting routine probiotic yields better outcomes compared with neonates treated at nonadopting NICUs in a cohort study.
The researchers extracted details from d Vermont Oxford Network data on neonates with very low birth weight in US neonatal ICUs from 2012 to 2019. The patients were allocated to probiotics adoption vs nonadoption. Adopting NICUs was defined as those previously or currently treating at least 20% of neonates with a very low birth weight with probiotics.
A difference-in-differences analysis compared changes in very low birth weight infant outcomes between adopting and nonadopting NICUs before and after hospital-level adoption of probiotics. Rates of NEC, sepsis, and in-hospital mortality were the primary outcomes. Sepsis was defined as a fungal or bacterial infection after day 3 of birth. Additional analyses used the neonates' proportion treated with probiotics in delivery NICU and the year of each neonate.
The study revealed the following findings:
• The analysis comprised 307 905 neonates with VLBW (mean gestational age, 28.4 weeks; 50.0% male) at 807 hospitals in the US.
• There was an increase in the rate of probiotic treatment of neonates with VLBW from 4.1% of neonates in 2012 to 12.6% of neonates in 2019.
• Only 16.5% of NICUs adopted probiotics by 2019, with 76.3% of neonates with VLBW receiving probiotics in 2019 at adopting NICUs.
• There was a decline in the incidence of NEC by 18% at adopting NICUs (odds ratio [OR], 0.82) compared with nonadopting NICUs.
• Probiotic adoption was not associated with significantly reduced sepsis (OR, 1.11) or mortality (OR, 0.93).
The findings for probiotic adoption and NEC, mortality, and sepsis were smaller than predicted by the totality of randomized controlled trial evidence but are in line with a meta-analysis restricted to studies at low bias risk.
"These findings underscore the importance of monitoring the effectiveness of probiotics as they diffuse into neonatal practice beyond the setting of clinical trials," the researchers wrote. "The analysis also suggests a framework that might apply to postapproval effectiveness evaluations for other new clinical treatments, providing insight into how technology impacts patient outcomes as it diffuses into routine clinical practice."
Reference:
Agha L, Staiger D, Brown C, Soll RF, Horbar JD, Edwards EM. Association of Hospital Adoption of Probiotics With Outcomes Among Neonates With Very Low Birth Weight. JAMA Health Forum. 2023;4(5):e230960. doi:10.1001/jamahealthforum.2023.0960
