No Chest CT for Diagnosis of COVID-19, Says AJR
Leesburg -According to an open-access clinical Perspective article in the American Journal of Roentgenology (AJR),the radiology literature on coronavirus disease(COVID-19) pneumonia has consisted of limited retrospective studies that do not substantiate the use of CT as a diagnostic test for COVID-19."This is not to say these studies are not valuable," maintained lead investigator Constantine...
Leesburg -According to an open-access clinical Perspective article in the American Journal of Roentgenology (AJR),the radiology literature on coronavirus disease(COVID-19) pneumonia has consisted of limited retrospective studies that do not substantiate the use of CT as a diagnostic test for COVID-19.
"This is not to say these studies are not valuable," maintained lead investigator Constantine A. Raptis of Washington University in Saint Louis. Raptis, Travis S. Henry of the University of California-San Francisco, and nine co-authors from six institutions across the United States noted of the most frequently cited studies on the subject, reporting the various CT features of COVID-19 pneumonia remains"an important first step"in helping radiologists identify patients who may have COVID-19 in the appropriate clinical environment.
"However," they continue,"test performance and management issues arise when inappropriate and potentially overreaching conclusions regarding the diagnostic performance of CT for COVID-19 pneumonia are based on low-quality studies with biased cohorts, confounding variables, and faulty design characteristics."
Because misdiagnosing even a single patient (i.e., obtaining a false-negative finding) could result in large outbreaks among future contacts, understanding the potential effects of selection bias is important in determining sensitivity. As Raptis and colleagues explained, "if a study cohort contains patients who are more likely to have a true-positive finding and less likely to have a false-negative finding, the sensitivity will be overestimated."
The specificity and positive predictive value of a laboratory test—in the case of COVID-19, reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR)—are based on its ability to limit false-positive findings. Acknowledgingfalse-positive-PCR results are possible, Raptis, Henry, et al. maintained they are often caused by contamination and are likely insignificant in the setting of assays forCOVID-19.CT, on the other hand, does not test for singular features unique to the disease, and even those features most characteristic of COVID-19 pneumonia—peripheral, bilateral ground-glass opacities typically in the lower lobes—have been reported in a number of other conditions, both infectious and noninfectious.
CT in Clinical Practice
Finally, Raptisand colleagues addressed the hazards of wide deployment of CT: overuse of hospital resources, including the use of PPE already limited in availability but required to safely perform CT studies; clustering of affected and nonaffected patients in the radiology department, increasing the risk of disease transmission among imaging staff.
"At present," the authors of this AJR article concluded,"CT should be reserved for evaluation of complications of COVID-19 pneumonia or for assessment if alternative diagnoses are suspected."