This site is intended for Healthcare professionals only.

Stop Quackery in name of testing Laboratories

Stop Quackery in name of testing Laboratories

Delhi Medical Council recently suspended a pathologist for a period of one year on account of professional misconduct for selling his name and signature to a laboratory which did not even have required infrastructure. This incident has brought up issue of quackery prevalent in field of diagnostics and illegal laboratories mushrooming in National Capital Territory of Delhi.

It is a known fact that, in absence of a stringent laws, there has been a sharp rise in number of illegal laboratories in  many parts of Capital city in recent times especially in slums and semi urban areas. Most of these labs are being run by technicians, holding either a Diploma in Medical Laboratory Technology (DMLT) or  a Certificate degree in Medical Laboratory Technology (CMLT), which qualifies one to conduct tests but only under a pathologist’s supervision. In most of such places the lab technicians just use the electronic signature of a pathologist who has agreed for financial consideration, to put his signature on reports not prepared under his supervision. However, there are some laboratories which do not even have full-time or part-time qualified technicians and the pathologists have not even visited the laboratories even once.

This illegal practice is  not  confined to Delhi only and is  prevalent throughout India.Earlier in this year Maharashtra Medical Council suspended four pathologists for selling their signatures to private laboratories many of which did not even have qualified technicians working in it.

As of now a person wishing to run a laboratory has to acquire Shops and Establishments License from the municipal corporation and show that they have a pathologist on rolls. The state government does not carry out due diligence to ensure that a qualified pathologist is present at all times to sign reports. In spite of the fact,that there have been interim orders of various high courts including Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and Andhra Pradesh clearly stating that only a pathologist possessing a M.D. degree in Pathology can run a lab and sign reports. Due to state governments not able to enforce the honorable Court’s orders lab technicians and quacks are openly flouting court orders.

Laboratory services are an integral part of disease diagnosis, treatment and for monitoring response to treatment. Laboratory tests are used to support diagnosis in patient care therefore test results should be reliable, accurate and reproducible. It is therefore necessary to ensure that the tests have been conducted properly following standard operative procedures an under supervision of a qualified pathologist.

In India, the law permits pathologists to work in multiple laboratories, but norms demand that they should be physically present while samples are being tested in the laboratory, before they make an analysis and sign the report. The law doesn’t lay out guidelines as to how many labs a pathologist can be associated to as a point of time. Seeing this gaping hole, pathologists are selling their signatures and certifying reports  of tests which have not been conducted under their supervision. All such pathologists,who are violating rules to generate extra income must be severely punished by the Medical Council of respective state in which they practice.

A high level  committee needs to  be constituted to  lay down guidelines for maximumnumber of laboratories a pathologist could attach himself or herself with. This will ensure that a pathologist is not attached with a lab just for monetary benefits. It is the  need of the hour that this unethical practice of running illegal laboratories should be stopped. Although the technicians who are running labs by themselves are not registered with Medical Councils and no direct action can be initiated against them by respective Medical Councils but they can certainly be booked under the legal provisions of Anti-Quackery. Furthermore ,Clinical Establishment Act Standards for Medical (Clinical) Laboratory with respect to space requirement, Infrastructure,Essential Furniture and fixture, essential equipment , human resource requirement and medical records  may be strictly enforced  at the time of  Registration of Laboratory and its Regulated from time to time.

Please share your views how this menace can be tackled.

Source: self
2 comment(s) on Stop Quackery in name of testing Laboratories

Share your Opinion Disclaimer

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Most Voted
  1. user
    Dr Naresh Mahajan August 10, 2017, 9:18 am

    Dear Sir
    Many of us practicing in Delhi are outsourcing our lab investigations to Pathological laboratories which may be having only VISITING PATHOLOGISTS!!!
    What should be done in such a case. The reports usually have primted signatures of the Pathologist and just a scribble as a signature.
    In such a case who is responsible for any mistake etc. , the Doctor sending the sample, or, the Lab. owner, or the Pathologist selling/ lending his signatures.
    What Precautions we should take in sending our samples to any lab.
    Your detailed expert advice will be very appreciated.
    Thanking you
    Yours sincerely
    Dr Naresh Mahajan

  2. All of us (doctors) should feel responsible for this menace. Putting up a beautiful face to a rotten system of practice will take all of us to hell and we may not know but doctors abroad laugh at us. Our system of practice and conduct is not generating any respect no more. The only thing it generates is money.