Medical Dialogues
  • Dermatology
Login Register
This site is intended for healthcare professionals only
Login Register
  • MD Brand Connect
  • Vaccine Hub
  • MDTV
    • Breaking News
    • Medical News Today
    • Health News Today
    • Latest
    • Journal Club
    • Medico Legal Update
    • Latest Webinars
    • MD Shorts
    • Health Dialogues
  • Fact Check
  • Health Dialogues
Medical Dialogues
  • Medical News & Guidelines
      • Anesthesiology
      • Cardiology and CTVS
      • Critical Care
      • Dentistry
      • Dermatology
      • Diabetes and Endocrinology
      • ENT
      • Gastroenterology
      • Medicine
      • Nephrology
      • Neurology
      • Obstretics-Gynaecology
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Orthopaedics
      • Pediatrics-Neonatology
      • Psychiatry
      • Pulmonology
      • Radiology
      • Surgery
      • Urology
      • Laboratory Medicine
      • Diet
      • Nursing
      • Paramedical
      • Physiotherapy
  • Health news
      • Doctor News
      • Government Policies
      • Hospital & Diagnostics
      • International Health News
      • Medical Organization News
      • Medico Legal News
      • NBE News
      • NMC News
  • Fact Check
      • Bone Health Fact Check
      • Brain Health Fact Check
      • Cancer Related Fact Check
      • Child Care Fact Check
      • Dental and oral health fact check
      • Diabetes and metabolic health fact check
      • Diet and Nutrition Fact Check
      • Eye and ENT Care Fact Check
      • Fitness fact check
      • Gut health fact check
      • Heart health fact check
      • Kidney health fact check
      • Medical education fact check
      • Men's health fact check
      • Respiratory fact check
      • Skin and hair care fact check
      • Vaccine and Immunization fact check
      • Women's health fact check
  • AYUSH
    • Ayurveda
    • Homeopathy
    • Siddha
    • Unani
    • Yoga
  • State News
      • Andaman and Nicobar Islands
      • Andhra Pradesh
      • Arunachal Pradesh
      • Assam
      • Bihar
      • Chandigarh
      • Chattisgarh
      • Dadra and Nagar Haveli
      • Daman and Diu
      • Delhi
      • Goa
      • Gujarat
      • Haryana
      • Himachal Pradesh
      • Jammu & Kashmir
      • Jharkhand
      • Karnataka
      • Kerala
      • Ladakh
      • Lakshadweep
      • Madhya Pradesh
      • Maharashtra
      • Manipur
      • Meghalaya
      • Mizoram
      • Nagaland
      • Odisha
      • Puducherry
      • Punjab
      • Rajasthan
      • Sikkim
      • Tamil Nadu
      • Telangana
      • Tripura
      • Uttar Pradesh
      • Uttrakhand
      • West Bengal
  • Medical Education
      • Ayush Education News
      • Dentistry Education News
      • Medical Admission News
      • Medical Colleges News
      • Medical Courses News
      • Medical Universities News
      • Nursing education News
      • Paramedical Education News
      • Study Abroad
  • Industry
      • Health Investment News
      • Health Startup News
      • Medical Devices News
      • Pharma News
      • Pharmacy Education News
      • Industry Perspective
  • MDTV
      • Health Dialogues MDTV
      • Health News today MDTV
      • Latest Videos MDTV
      • Latest Webinars MDTV
      • MD shorts MDTV
      • Medical News Today MDTV
      • Medico Legal Update MDTV
      • Top Videos MDTV
      • Health Perspectives MDTV
      • Journal Club MDTV
      • Medical Dialogues Show
This site is intended for healthcare professionals only
LoginRegister
Medical Dialogues
LoginRegister
  • Home
  • Medical news & Guidelines
    • Anesthesiology
    • Cardiology and CTVS
    • Critical Care
    • Dentistry
    • Dermatology
    • Diabetes and Endocrinology
    • ENT
    • Gastroenterology
    • Medicine
    • Nephrology
    • Neurology
    • Obstretics-Gynaecology
    • Oncology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Orthopaedics
    • Pediatrics-Neonatology
    • Psychiatry
    • Pulmonology
    • Radiology
    • Surgery
    • Urology
    • Laboratory Medicine
    • Diet
    • Nursing
    • Paramedical
    • Physiotherapy
  • Health news
    • Doctor News
    • Government Policies
    • Hospital & Diagnostics
    • International Health News
    • Medical Organization News
    • Medico Legal News
    • NBE News
    • NMC News
  • Fact Check
    • Bone Health Fact Check
    • Brain Health Fact Check
    • Cancer Related Fact Check
    • Child Care Fact Check
    • Dental and oral health fact check
    • Diabetes and metabolic health fact check
    • Diet and Nutrition Fact Check
    • Eye and ENT Care Fact Check
    • Fitness fact check
    • Gut health fact check
    • Heart health fact check
    • Kidney health fact check
    • Medical education fact check
    • Men's health fact check
    • Respiratory fact check
    • Skin and hair care fact check
    • Vaccine and Immunization fact check
    • Women's health fact check
  • AYUSH
    • Ayurveda
      • Ayurveda Giuidelines
      • Ayurveda News
    • Homeopathy
      • Homeopathy Guidelines
      • Homeopathy News
    • Siddha
      • Siddha Guidelines
      • Siddha News
    • Unani
      • Unani Guidelines
      • Unani News
    • Yoga
      • Yoga Guidelines
      • Yoga News
  • State News
    • Andaman and Nicobar Islands
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Arunachal Pradesh
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chandigarh
    • Chattisgarh
    • Dadra and Nagar Haveli
    • Daman and Diu
    • Delhi
    • Goa
    • Gujarat
    • Haryana
    • Himachal Pradesh
    • Jammu & Kashmir
    • Jharkhand
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Ladakh
    • Lakshadweep
    • Madhya Pradesh
    • Maharashtra
    • Manipur
    • Meghalaya
    • Mizoram
    • Nagaland
    • Odisha
    • Puducherry
    • Punjab
    • Rajasthan
    • Sikkim
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
    • Tripura
    • Uttar Pradesh
    • Uttrakhand
    • West Bengal
  • Medical Education
    • Ayush Education News
    • Dentistry Education News
    • Medical Admission News
    • Medical Colleges News
    • Medical Courses News
    • Medical Universities News
    • Nursing education News
    • Paramedical Education News
    • Study Abroad
  • Industry
    • Health Investment News
    • Health Startup News
    • Medical Devices News
    • Pharma News
      • CDSCO (Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation) News
    • Pharmacy Education News
    • Industry Perspective
  • Home
  • Editors pick
  • New Delhi: Apollo...

New Delhi: Apollo Doctor exonerated of medical negligence

Meghna A SinghaniaWritten by Meghna A Singhania Published On 2016-12-05T12:58:08+05:30  |  Updated On 5 Dec 2016 12:58 PM IST
New Delhi: Apollo Doctor exonerated of medical negligence
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • whatsapp
  • Telegram
  • Email
Consumer Protection Act should not be a halter round the neck

New Delhi: Doctors can only provide treatment and cannot guarantee cure. The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, in a recent judgment of Satender Kumar v/s INDRAPRASTHA APOLLO HOSPITAL & ANR, was found implying the same, where it was  seen reiterating that Consumer Protection Act should not be a halter round the neck.

The case is that of one Satendra Kumar, who was admitted to Indraprastha Apollo Hospital in 2012 under the care of orthopaedic surgeon Dr Raju Vaishya after sustaining a fracture on his right leg due to a fall. The patient suffered a "Right distal femur shaft fracture with CAD" and the doctor performed "closed reduction and internal fixation by nailing (AO interlocking nail 400 x 11 mm) on 14/06/12 under GA". Thereafter the patient  met with another accident in the year 2013 and this time suffered a fracture on his left leg. He was again taken to Apollo Hospital, where Dr Vaishya performed an Open Reduction and intramedullary nailing left proximal femur.

The patient complained that both the surgeries were not successful as he suffered time and again late night pain. In the year 2014, the rod inserted in his right leg got bent for which he got operated  at Saket City where Dr U. K. Sahoo diagnosed it as a ‘Non-union fracture shaft of femur Right with implant in situ" and re-operated on his right leg performing exchange nailing right femur (Synthes) with Bone grafting (type of Anesthesia – CSE)




In the year 2016, the patient again complained of pain in his left leg, for which he had to go for an operation the fourth time namely, implant removal, ORIF and Bone grafting, which was again performed by Dr U.K.Sadhoo at Saket City Hospital.

The patient after having gone 4 surgeries in 5 years, filed a case against Apollo Hospital and the doctor, demanding a compensation of Rs. 1 crore from the opponents for medical negligence, towards medical expenses (operations), Rs. 20 lakhs, towards mental agony, harassment, Rs 55 lakhs and Rs. 35 lakhs towards loss of time, disruption of work, damage to reputation as he was in continuous pain since his first surgery in 2012.

The commission dismissed the complaint based on the point of limitation as time- barred and devoid of merit. It held that:





  • On the basis  of Discharge Summaries, Clinical and Surgical note, the commission dismissed the cause of action to be a continuous one stating that there is nothing on record to prove that patient was continuously suffering after 25.5.2013. Therefore, the complainant ought to have filed the complaint within two years from 25.05.2013. Accordingly, it is barred by limitation as under Section 24A of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986.






Even on the basis of merit, the court dismissed the case stating that





  • “Non Union of fracture” is an accepted complication following fracture surgery. It is not medical negligence. Patient is 66 years of age, known case of CAD and HTN. Non-healing of facture depends on the health condition of the person, his age and so many other factors. As per medical text books like Campbell’s Orthopedics, Wastone Jones Fracture and Joint Injuries, the reasons for non-union are



  1. Avascular necrosis (the blood supply was interrupted by the fracture)

  2. The two ends are not apposed (that is, they are not next to each other)

  3. Infection (particularly Osteomyelitis)

  4. The fracture is not fixed (that is, the two ends are still mobile)

  5. Soft-tissue imposition (there is muscle or ligament covering the broken ends and preventing them from touching each other)







  • The commission further held that the orthopaedic surgeon at Apollo Hospital on both the operations on both fractured legs on different occasions (2012 and 2013) as per Standard procedure and practice.


 I do not find any deviation in the practice from OP-2. Bending of inserted rod in the long bone is not due to negligence of orthopaedic surgeon, thus blaming the OP-2 doctor is not acceptable.


  •  Stating an earlier Supreme Court judgement, the commission went on to add:





“When a patient dies or suffers some mishap, there is a tendency to blame the doctor for this. Things have gone wrong and, therefore, somebody must be punished for it. However, it is well known that even the best professionals, what to say of the average professional, sometimes have failures. A lawyer cannot win every case in his professional career but surely he cannot be penalized for losing a case provided he appeared in it and made his submissions.”

With this the commission dismissed the complaint both on the grounds of limitation as well as the merit.

You can read the full judgement below






Meghna A Singhania
Meghna A Singhania

Meghna A Singhania is the founder and Editor-in-Chief at Medical Dialogues. An Economics graduate from Delhi University and a post graduate from London School of Economics and Political Science, her key research interest lies in health economics, and policy making in health and medical sector in the country. She is a member of the Association of Healthcare Journalists. She can be contacted at meghna@medicaldialogues.in. Contact no. 011-43720751

Show Full Article
Next Story

Editorial

ABYSS Trial Finds Elevated BP, HR & Deleterious CV Outcomes After Beta blocker Withdrawal Post-MI: EuroPCR 2025 Update

ABYSS Trial Finds Elevated BP, HR & Deleterious CV Outcomes After Beta blocker Withdrawal Post-MI:...

Aspirin Use in Male Smokers Aged 40-45 Years with Hypertension: Identifying the Ideal Candidates

Aspirin Use in Male Smokers Aged 40-45 Years with Hypertension: Identifying the Ideal Candidates

National Consensus 2025 on Role of Bisoprolol Across CV Continuum in Women: Top 10 Takeaways

National Consensus 2025 on Role of Bisoprolol Across CV Continuum in Women: Top 10 Takeaways

Relevance of Pioglitazone in Indian T2DM Care Continuum

Relevance of Pioglitazone in Indian T2DM Care Continuum

Azmarda Outperforms Generic Sacubitril/Valsartan in HFrEF Management, says new study

Azmarda Outperforms Generic Sacubitril/Valsartan in HFrEF Management, says new study

View All

Journal Club Today

Study Unveils Molecular Links between Air Pollution and Negative Birth Outcomes

Study Unveils Molecular Links between Air Pollution and Negative Birth Outcomes

View All

Health News Today

Health Bulletin 06/June/2025

Health Bulletin 06/June/2025

View All
© 2022 All Rights Reserved.
Powered By: Hocalwire
X
We use cookies for analytics, advertising and to improve our site. You agree to our use of cookies by continuing to use our site. To know more, see our Cookie Policy and Cookie Settings.Ok