Medical Dialogues
  • Dermatology
Login Register
This site is intended for healthcare professionals only
Login Register
  • MD Brand Connect
  • Vaccine Hub
  • MDTV
    • Breaking News
    • Medical News Today
    • Health News Today
    • Latest
    • Journal Club
    • Medico Legal Update
    • Latest Webinars
    • MD Shorts
    • Health Dialogues
  • Fact Check
  • Health Dialogues
Medical Dialogues
  • Medical News & Guidelines
      • Anesthesiology
      • Cardiology and CTVS
      • Critical Care
      • Dentistry
      • Dermatology
      • Diabetes and Endocrinology
      • ENT
      • Gastroenterology
      • Medicine
      • Nephrology
      • Neurology
      • Obstretics-Gynaecology
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Orthopaedics
      • Pediatrics-Neonatology
      • Psychiatry
      • Pulmonology
      • Radiology
      • Surgery
      • Urology
      • Laboratory Medicine
      • Diet
      • Nursing
      • Paramedical
      • Physiotherapy
  • Health news
      • Doctor News
      • Government Policies
      • Hospital & Diagnostics
      • International Health News
      • Medical Organization News
      • Medico Legal News
      • NBE News
      • NMC News
  • Fact Check
      • Bone Health Fact Check
      • Brain Health Fact Check
      • Cancer Related Fact Check
      • Child Care Fact Check
      • Dental and oral health fact check
      • Diabetes and metabolic health fact check
      • Diet and Nutrition Fact Check
      • Eye and ENT Care Fact Check
      • Fitness fact check
      • Gut health fact check
      • Heart health fact check
      • Kidney health fact check
      • Medical education fact check
      • Men's health fact check
      • Respiratory fact check
      • Skin and hair care fact check
      • Vaccine and Immunization fact check
      • Women's health fact check
  • AYUSH
    • Ayurveda
    • Homeopathy
    • Siddha
    • Unani
    • Yoga
  • State News
      • Andaman and Nicobar Islands
      • Andhra Pradesh
      • Arunachal Pradesh
      • Assam
      • Bihar
      • Chandigarh
      • Chattisgarh
      • Dadra and Nagar Haveli
      • Daman and Diu
      • Delhi
      • Goa
      • Gujarat
      • Haryana
      • Himachal Pradesh
      • Jammu & Kashmir
      • Jharkhand
      • Karnataka
      • Kerala
      • Ladakh
      • Lakshadweep
      • Madhya Pradesh
      • Maharashtra
      • Manipur
      • Meghalaya
      • Mizoram
      • Nagaland
      • Odisha
      • Puducherry
      • Punjab
      • Rajasthan
      • Sikkim
      • Tamil Nadu
      • Telangana
      • Tripura
      • Uttar Pradesh
      • Uttrakhand
      • West Bengal
  • Medical Education
      • Ayush Education News
      • Dentistry Education News
      • Medical Admission News
      • Medical Colleges News
      • Medical Courses News
      • Medical Universities News
      • Nursing education News
      • Paramedical Education News
      • Study Abroad
  • Industry
      • Health Investment News
      • Health Startup News
      • Medical Devices News
      • Pharma News
      • Pharmacy Education News
      • Industry Perspective
  • MDTV
      • Health Dialogues MDTV
      • Health News today MDTV
      • Latest Videos MDTV
      • Latest Webinars MDTV
      • MD shorts MDTV
      • Medical News Today MDTV
      • Medico Legal Update MDTV
      • Top Videos MDTV
      • Health Perspectives MDTV
      • Journal Club MDTV
      • Medical Dialogues Show
This site is intended for healthcare professionals only
LoginRegister
Medical Dialogues
LoginRegister
  • Home
  • Medical news & Guidelines
    • Anesthesiology
    • Cardiology and CTVS
    • Critical Care
    • Dentistry
    • Dermatology
    • Diabetes and Endocrinology
    • ENT
    • Gastroenterology
    • Medicine
    • Nephrology
    • Neurology
    • Obstretics-Gynaecology
    • Oncology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Orthopaedics
    • Pediatrics-Neonatology
    • Psychiatry
    • Pulmonology
    • Radiology
    • Surgery
    • Urology
    • Laboratory Medicine
    • Diet
    • Nursing
    • Paramedical
    • Physiotherapy
  • Health news
    • Doctor News
    • Government Policies
    • Hospital & Diagnostics
    • International Health News
    • Medical Organization News
    • Medico Legal News
    • NBE News
    • NMC News
  • Fact Check
    • Bone Health Fact Check
    • Brain Health Fact Check
    • Cancer Related Fact Check
    • Child Care Fact Check
    • Dental and oral health fact check
    • Diabetes and metabolic health fact check
    • Diet and Nutrition Fact Check
    • Eye and ENT Care Fact Check
    • Fitness fact check
    • Gut health fact check
    • Heart health fact check
    • Kidney health fact check
    • Medical education fact check
    • Men's health fact check
    • Respiratory fact check
    • Skin and hair care fact check
    • Vaccine and Immunization fact check
    • Women's health fact check
  • AYUSH
    • Ayurveda
      • Ayurveda Giuidelines
      • Ayurveda News
    • Homeopathy
      • Homeopathy Guidelines
      • Homeopathy News
    • Siddha
      • Siddha Guidelines
      • Siddha News
    • Unani
      • Unani Guidelines
      • Unani News
    • Yoga
      • Yoga Guidelines
      • Yoga News
  • State News
    • Andaman and Nicobar Islands
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Arunachal Pradesh
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chandigarh
    • Chattisgarh
    • Dadra and Nagar Haveli
    • Daman and Diu
    • Delhi
    • Goa
    • Gujarat
    • Haryana
    • Himachal Pradesh
    • Jammu & Kashmir
    • Jharkhand
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Ladakh
    • Lakshadweep
    • Madhya Pradesh
    • Maharashtra
    • Manipur
    • Meghalaya
    • Mizoram
    • Nagaland
    • Odisha
    • Puducherry
    • Punjab
    • Rajasthan
    • Sikkim
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
    • Tripura
    • Uttar Pradesh
    • Uttrakhand
    • West Bengal
  • Medical Education
    • Ayush Education News
    • Dentistry Education News
    • Medical Admission News
    • Medical Colleges News
    • Medical Courses News
    • Medical Universities News
    • Nursing education News
    • Paramedical Education News
    • Study Abroad
  • Industry
    • Health Investment News
    • Health Startup News
    • Medical Devices News
    • Pharma News
      • CDSCO (Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation) News
    • Pharmacy Education News
    • Industry Perspective
  • Home
  • News
  • Health news
  • Expert Medical...

Expert Medical Opinions on Disability to Prevail Over Inferences from Direct Child Interactions: SC

Kajal RajputWritten by Kajal Rajput Published On 2025-03-05T12:03:24+05:30  |  Updated On 5 March 2025 12:03 PM IST
Supreme Court of India

Supreme Court of India

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • whatsapp
  • Telegram
  • Email

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday ruled that in child custody matters involving individuals with cognitive impairments, expert medical opinions confirming a disability should be prioritized over inferences drawn from direct interactions with the child.

According to a UNI report, a bench comprising Justice Surya Kant, Justice Dipankar Datta, and Justice Ujjal Bhuyan allowed the appeal and granted custody of the child to the Appellant-mother, permitting her to take him back to the USA.

The court was hearing a dispute over the custody of a 22-year-old individual with cognitive abilities equivalent to an 8 to 10-year-old child.

Also Read:Supreme Court calls for mechanism for complaints Against Misleading medical Ads

The case arose after the appellant-mother filed a habeas corpus petition in the Madras High Court, seeking custody of her child, alleging that the Respondent-father had taken him to India from the USA without her consent, thereby violating a U.S. court order granting custodial rights to the appellant.

The appellant argued that although her son was legally an adult, his cognitive limitations rendered him incapable of making independent and complex decisions, particularly regarding long-term residence and financial matters.

Despite detailed medical reports confirming the child’s cognitive impairment, the High Court denied custody to the mother based on a brief oral interaction with the child.

Dissatisfied with the High Court’s decision, the Appellant approached the Supreme Court.

Overturning the High Court’s ruling, the Supreme Court, in a judgment authored by Justice Surya Kant, held that the High Court erred in denying custody to the mother.

The Supreme Court emphasised that a brief oral exchange with a child lacking independent decision-making capacity could not serve as a basis for a custody ruling, especially when medical expert reports categorically establish the child's cognitive limitations.

The court held that when a specialist’s evaluation confirms a child's inability to make independent decisions, custody rulings should not be influenced by the child’s expressed or implied consent, as this could have significant consequences for the child’s well-being.

“In cases where there is any doubt about an individual’s capacity to make independent decisions, and a specialist, domain expert, or medical professional has provided a definitive opinion confirming a disability, the Court should accord due weight to that expert assessment, the Apex court held.

The bench further said, "If an expert’s report concludes that the mental or physical age of the concerned individual is significantly below the age of majority, no 'implied' or 'express' consent should be inferred for any decision that could have a substantial impact on them. Unless there are compelling reasons to doubt an expert’s report, courts must exercise extreme caution before arriving at a contrary conclusion", reports UNI.

"Keeping this principle in mind, we find that as A..(child) was assessed to have the cognitive abilities of an 8 to 10-year-old child, the reasoning adopted by the High Court in concluding that he had consented to stay in India is seriously flawed,” the top judiciary observed.

The SC relied on medical evaluations from the National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS), Bengaluru, and the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare, both of which confirmed that the child had a cognitive functioning level akin to that of an 8 to 10-year-old child.

Reiterating the significance of expert medical opinions, the Court stated, “If an expert’s report concludes that the mental or physical age of the person concerned is well below the age of majority, no 'implied' or 'express' consent should be inferred for any act that could have significant consequences for the individual.”

The court further observed, “While courts are entitled to form an independent opinion, they cannot disregard expert evaluations arbitrarily. In cases involving individuals with severe cognitive impairments, courts must ensure that scientific assessments in specialized medical fields are given due consideration.

If any doubt arises regarding an expert report’s findings, the appropriate course of action is to seek an additional evaluation from a reputable medical institution rather than dismissing expert medical opinions outright.”

Accordingly, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal and granted custody of the child to the appellant mother, permitting her to take him back to the USA.

Also Read:Supreme Court rejects review plea, says no exemption for doctors under CPA

Supreme Courtchild disabilityMadras High CourtNational Institute of Mental Health and NeurosciencesNIMHANS
Kajal Rajput
Kajal Rajput

    Kajal joined Medical Dialogue in 2019 for the Latest Health News. She has done her graduation from the University of Delhi. She mainly covers news about the Latest Healthcare. She can be contacted at editorial@medicaldialogues.in.

    Show Full Article
    Next Story

    Editorial

    National Consensus 2025 on Role of Bisoprolol Across CV Continuum in Women: Top 10 Takeaways

    National Consensus 2025 on Role of Bisoprolol Across CV Continuum in Women: Top 10 Takeaways

    Relevance of Pioglitazone in Indian T2DM Care Continuum

    Relevance of Pioglitazone in Indian T2DM Care Continuum

    Azmarda Outperforms Generic Sacubitril/Valsartan in HFrEF Management, says new study

    Azmarda Outperforms Generic Sacubitril/Valsartan in HFrEF Management, says new study

    First Indian Consensus on Managing Refractory Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Recommends Vonoprazan

    First Indian Consensus on Managing Refractory Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Recommends Vonoprazan

    Re-visiting the Role of Pneumococcal Vaccination in Patients with Cardiovascular Diseases

    Re-visiting the Role of Pneumococcal Vaccination in Patients with Cardiovascular Diseases

    View All

    Journal Club Today

    Study Reveals Why Your Immune System Works Better in Daylight

    Study Reveals Why Your Immune System Works Better in Daylight

    View All

    Health News Today

    Health Bulletin 29/May/2025

    Health Bulletin 29/May/2025

    View All
    © 2022 All Rights Reserved.
    Powered By: Hocalwire
    X
    We use cookies for analytics, advertising and to improve our site. You agree to our use of cookies by continuing to use our site. To know more, see our Cookie Policy and Cookie Settings.Ok