- Home
- Medical news & Guidelines
- Anesthesiology
- Cardiology and CTVS
- Critical Care
- Dentistry
- Dermatology
- Diabetes and Endocrinology
- ENT
- Gastroenterology
- Medicine
- Nephrology
- Neurology
- Obstretics-Gynaecology
- Oncology
- Ophthalmology
- Orthopaedics
- Pediatrics-Neonatology
- Psychiatry
- Pulmonology
- Radiology
- Surgery
- Urology
- Laboratory Medicine
- Diet
- Nursing
- Paramedical
- Physiotherapy
- Health news
- Fact Check
- Bone Health Fact Check
- Brain Health Fact Check
- Cancer Related Fact Check
- Child Care Fact Check
- Dental and oral health fact check
- Diabetes and metabolic health fact check
- Diet and Nutrition Fact Check
- Eye and ENT Care Fact Check
- Fitness fact check
- Gut health fact check
- Heart health fact check
- Kidney health fact check
- Medical education fact check
- Men's health fact check
- Respiratory fact check
- Skin and hair care fact check
- Vaccine and Immunization fact check
- Women's health fact check
- AYUSH
- State News
- Andaman and Nicobar Islands
- Andhra Pradesh
- Arunachal Pradesh
- Assam
- Bihar
- Chandigarh
- Chattisgarh
- Dadra and Nagar Haveli
- Daman and Diu
- Delhi
- Goa
- Gujarat
- Haryana
- Himachal Pradesh
- Jammu & Kashmir
- Jharkhand
- Karnataka
- Kerala
- Ladakh
- Lakshadweep
- Madhya Pradesh
- Maharashtra
- Manipur
- Meghalaya
- Mizoram
- Nagaland
- Odisha
- Puducherry
- Punjab
- Rajasthan
- Sikkim
- Tamil Nadu
- Telangana
- Tripura
- Uttar Pradesh
- Uttrakhand
- West Bengal
- Medical Education
- Industry
Denied Pharmacist Registration Over Class 12 Biology Result, D.Pharm Graduate Gets HC Relief
Uttarakhand High CourtJustice Pankaj Purohit delivered the judgment on November 16, 2026, in Aashish Kumar v. State of Uttarakhand and Others, Writ Petition Misc. Single No. 2942 of 2025, bearing neutral citation 2026:UHC:10412. Kumar had approached the court under Article 226 of the Constitution, seeking a direction for his registration as a pharmacist.
The dispute arose after Kumar completed the two-year D.Pharm course at Government Polytechnic College, Lohaghat, but encountered an eligibility objection when he sought registration with the Uttarakhand Pharmacy Council. Although CBSE had declared his overall Class XII result as “Pass”, the Council objected that he had not passed Biology as required for admission to the pharmacy course.
According to the background recorded in the judgment, Kumar belongs to the Scheduled Caste category and passed Class X in 2019. He subsequently appeared in the Joint Entrance Examination Polytechnic, JEEP-2021, securing Rank 137. After being declared passed in the CBSE Class XII examination, he participated in counselling and obtained admission to the D.Pharm course after submitting his educational documents.
His Class XII marks included 20 in Biology theory and 29 in practicals, aggregating to 49. The objection concerned his passing status in Biology despite the overall “Pass” result recorded by CBSE.
Kumar completed D.Pharm in 2023 with First Division and thereafter completed the mandatory three-month practical training under Regulation 20 of the Education Regulations framed under the Pharmacy Act, 1948. He then approached the Pharmacy Council for registration, but his application was not processed.
After seeking information under the Right to Information Act, 2005, he was informed that he was ineligible for registration because he had allegedly failed Biology in Class XII and consequently did not fulfil the eligibility requirements referred to under Section 32(2) of the Pharmacy Act, 1948. The judgment records that the Council also acknowledged a lapse by the institution in admitting him without ensuring compliance with the prescribed eligibility conditions.
Kumar subsequently appeared in the Senior Secondary Examination conducted by NIOS and passed, securing 82 marks in Biology, 76 in Chemistry and 82 in Physics. He relied on this later qualification, together with his completed diploma and practical training, to support his request for registration.
Represented by advocate Vikram Singh Dhapola, Kumar argued that he had submitted his Class X and Class XII marksheets at the time of admission and had neither concealed material information nor committed fraud or misrepresentation. His counsel maintained that the college had admitted him after checking his documents and that responsibility for verifying his eligibility rested with the institution.
The petitioner emphasised that he had successfully completed the entire diploma course and the prescribed practical training. Since the Pharmacy Council itself had acknowledged the institution’s lapse, he argued that the consequences of that mistake should not fall entirely on him.
His counsel further submitted that the subsequent NIOS qualification supplied the requisite subject qualifications. Denying registration despite these circumstances, the petitioner argued, would cause grave injustice and jeopardise his career and future prospects for no fault of his own.
Opposing the petition, the respondents maintained that the eligibility requirements governing admission to D.Pharm were mandatory. They argued that Kumar had failed to secure the requisite passing marks in Biology in his CBSE Class XII examination and was therefore ineligible when admitted.
The respondents submitted that passing the prescribed qualifying subjects—Physics, Chemistry and Biology or Mathematics—was essential for admission. According to them, completing the diploma and practical training could not, by itself, create eligibility for registration where the statutory admission requirements had not been met.
They also disputed the effect of Kumar’s later NIOS qualification. Their position was that subsequently obtaining the qualification could not automatically validate his earlier admission or confer a retrospective right to registration. On that basis, they defended the Council’s refusal to register him.
The State was represented by Shushil Vashistha, while Seema Sah appeared for respondent No. 2, according to the appearances recorded in the judgment.
Examining the dispute, the court noted that Kumar’s overall CBSE Senior Secondary result was “Pass” and that he had been admitted to the government polytechnic after submitting his educational records. It also recognised his successful completion of D.Pharm with First Division and the mandatory practical training.
A central consideration was the absence of any allegation that Kumar had concealed his qualifications, produced forged documents or obtained admission through fraud. The court contrasted this with the acknowledged failure of the institution to ensure compliance with the eligibility requirements before admitting him.
The court observed:
“In such circumstances, the petitioner cannot be made to suffer for an error or negligence committed by the educational institution, particularly when all relevant documents had been disclosed by him at the time of admission.”
Justice Purohit nevertheless expressly recognised that statutory eligibility requirements could not simply be disregarded on grounds of fairness. The judgment stated:
“This Court is conscious of the fact that the eligibility conditions prescribed under the Pharmacy Act, 1948, and the regulations framed thereunder are mandatory in nature and cannot be overlooked merely on equitable considerations.”
At the same time, the court held that Kumar’s subsequent NIOS qualification was relevant to assessing his claim. It noted his marks in Biology, Chemistry and Physics and observed that he could not be presumed to know the minimum marks prescribed for registration when he had disclosed his records to the authorities.
The court also recorded that the percentage he had entered was the aggregate of his five best subjects. It reiterated that the respondents had not alleged that he withheld documents, submitted forged records or misrepresented his qualifications.
In considering how the authorities should address the claim, the court said they were required to examine the later qualification, the diploma certificate issued by the competent authority, completion of practical training and the circumstances in which admission had been granted.
The court further observed:
“The petitioner's claim cannot be rejected merely by attributing the entire responsibility for the admission-related lapse to him, without examining the effect of his subsequent qualification and the applicable statutory provisions.”
Ultimately, the High Court allowed the writ petition and directed registration, rather than merely directing reconsideration of Kumar’s application.
The exact operative direction in paragraph 10 reads:
“Accordingly writ petition stands allowed. Respondent-Competent Authority is directed to register the petitioner as Pharmacist based on his course completion certificate given by respondent no.2 and respondent no.4.”
The ruling grants relief to Kumar in light of the circumstances examined by the court: full disclosure of his educational records, the institution’s admission-related lapse, successful completion of the diploma and practical training, and his subsequent NIOS qualification. The judgment specifies no deadline for completing the registration.
To view the order, click the link below:
Mpharm (Pharmacology)
Susmita Roy, B pharm, M pharm Pharmacology, graduated from Gurunanak Institute of Pharmaceutical Science and Technology with a bachelor's degree in Pharmacy. She is currently working as an assistant professor at Haldia Institute of Pharmacy in West Bengal. She has been part of Medical Dialogues since March 2021.

