Medical Dialogues
  • Dermatology
Login Register
This site is intended for healthcare professionals only
Login Register
  • MD Brand Connect
  • Vaccine Hub
  • MDTV
    • Breaking News
    • Medical News Today
    • Health News Today
    • Latest
    • Journal Club
    • Medico Legal Update
    • Latest Webinars
    • MD Shorts
    • Health Dialogues
  • Fact Check
  • Health Dialogues
Medical Dialogues
  • Medical News & Guidelines
      • Anesthesiology
      • Cardiology and CTVS
      • Critical Care
      • Dentistry
      • Dermatology
      • Diabetes and Endocrinology
      • ENT
      • Gastroenterology
      • Medicine
      • Nephrology
      • Neurology
      • Obstretics-Gynaecology
      • Oncology
      • Ophthalmology
      • Orthopaedics
      • Pediatrics-Neonatology
      • Psychiatry
      • Pulmonology
      • Radiology
      • Surgery
      • Urology
      • Laboratory Medicine
      • Diet
      • Nursing
      • Paramedical
      • Physiotherapy
  • Health news
      • Doctor News
      • Government Policies
      • Hospital & Diagnostics
      • International Health News
      • Medical Organization News
      • Medico Legal News
      • NBE News
      • NMC News
  • Fact Check
      • Bone Health Fact Check
      • Brain Health Fact Check
      • Cancer Related Fact Check
      • Child Care Fact Check
      • Dental and oral health fact check
      • Diabetes and metabolic health fact check
      • Diet and Nutrition Fact Check
      • Eye and ENT Care Fact Check
      • Fitness fact check
      • Gut health fact check
      • Heart health fact check
      • Kidney health fact check
      • Medical education fact check
      • Men's health fact check
      • Respiratory fact check
      • Skin and hair care fact check
      • Vaccine and Immunization fact check
      • Women's health fact check
  • AYUSH
    • Ayurveda
    • Homeopathy
    • Siddha
    • Unani
    • Yoga
  • State News
      • Andaman and Nicobar Islands
      • Andhra Pradesh
      • Arunachal Pradesh
      • Assam
      • Bihar
      • Chandigarh
      • Chattisgarh
      • Dadra and Nagar Haveli
      • Daman and Diu
      • Delhi
      • Goa
      • Gujarat
      • Haryana
      • Himachal Pradesh
      • Jammu & Kashmir
      • Jharkhand
      • Karnataka
      • Kerala
      • Ladakh
      • Lakshadweep
      • Madhya Pradesh
      • Maharashtra
      • Manipur
      • Meghalaya
      • Mizoram
      • Nagaland
      • Odisha
      • Puducherry
      • Punjab
      • Rajasthan
      • Sikkim
      • Tamil Nadu
      • Telangana
      • Tripura
      • Uttar Pradesh
      • Uttrakhand
      • West Bengal
  • Medical Education
      • Ayush Education News
      • Dentistry Education News
      • Medical Admission News
      • Medical Colleges News
      • Medical Courses News
      • Medical Universities News
      • Nursing education News
      • Paramedical Education News
      • Study Abroad
  • Industry
      • Health Investment News
      • Health Startup News
      • Medical Devices News
      • Pharma News
      • Pharmacy Education News
      • Industry Perspective
  • MDTV
      • Health Dialogues MDTV
      • Health News today MDTV
      • Latest Videos MDTV
      • Latest Webinars MDTV
      • MD shorts MDTV
      • Medical News Today MDTV
      • Medico Legal Update MDTV
      • Top Videos MDTV
      • Health Perspectives MDTV
      • Journal Club MDTV
      • Medical Dialogues Show
This site is intended for healthcare professionals only
LoginRegister
Medical Dialogues
LoginRegister
  • Home
  • Medical news & Guidelines
    • Anesthesiology
    • Cardiology and CTVS
    • Critical Care
    • Dentistry
    • Dermatology
    • Diabetes and Endocrinology
    • ENT
    • Gastroenterology
    • Medicine
    • Nephrology
    • Neurology
    • Obstretics-Gynaecology
    • Oncology
    • Ophthalmology
    • Orthopaedics
    • Pediatrics-Neonatology
    • Psychiatry
    • Pulmonology
    • Radiology
    • Surgery
    • Urology
    • Laboratory Medicine
    • Diet
    • Nursing
    • Paramedical
    • Physiotherapy
  • Health news
    • Doctor News
    • Government Policies
    • Hospital & Diagnostics
    • International Health News
    • Medical Organization News
    • Medico Legal News
    • NBE News
    • NMC News
  • Fact Check
    • Bone Health Fact Check
    • Brain Health Fact Check
    • Cancer Related Fact Check
    • Child Care Fact Check
    • Dental and oral health fact check
    • Diabetes and metabolic health fact check
    • Diet and Nutrition Fact Check
    • Eye and ENT Care Fact Check
    • Fitness fact check
    • Gut health fact check
    • Heart health fact check
    • Kidney health fact check
    • Medical education fact check
    • Men's health fact check
    • Respiratory fact check
    • Skin and hair care fact check
    • Vaccine and Immunization fact check
    • Women's health fact check
  • AYUSH
    • Ayurveda
      • Ayurveda Giuidelines
      • Ayurveda News
    • Homeopathy
      • Homeopathy Guidelines
      • Homeopathy News
    • Siddha
      • Siddha Guidelines
      • Siddha News
    • Unani
      • Unani Guidelines
      • Unani News
    • Yoga
      • Yoga Guidelines
      • Yoga News
  • State News
    • Andaman and Nicobar Islands
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Arunachal Pradesh
    • Assam
    • Bihar
    • Chandigarh
    • Chattisgarh
    • Dadra and Nagar Haveli
    • Daman and Diu
    • Delhi
    • Goa
    • Gujarat
    • Haryana
    • Himachal Pradesh
    • Jammu & Kashmir
    • Jharkhand
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Ladakh
    • Lakshadweep
    • Madhya Pradesh
    • Maharashtra
    • Manipur
    • Meghalaya
    • Mizoram
    • Nagaland
    • Odisha
    • Puducherry
    • Punjab
    • Rajasthan
    • Sikkim
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
    • Tripura
    • Uttar Pradesh
    • Uttrakhand
    • West Bengal
  • Medical Education
    • Ayush Education News
    • Dentistry Education News
    • Medical Admission News
    • Medical Colleges News
    • Medical Courses News
    • Medical Universities News
    • Nursing education News
    • Paramedical Education News
    • Study Abroad
  • Industry
    • Health Investment News
    • Health Startup News
    • Medical Devices News
    • Pharma News
      • CDSCO (Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation) News
    • Pharmacy Education News
    • Industry Perspective
  • Home
  • News
  • Blog
  • No Negligence: Claim...

No Negligence: Claim of Rs 7.26 Crore against Tata Memorial Centre Dismissed

Meghna A SinghaniaWritten by Meghna A Singhania Published On 2017-10-06T15:48:32+05:30  |  Updated On 6 Oct 2017 3:48 PM IST
No Negligence: Claim of Rs 7.26 Crore against Tata Memorial Centre Dismissed
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • whatsapp
  • Telegram
  • Email
An important case for Radiologists, Pathologists and Oncologist in particular...

The judgment starts with the preface which clarifies the case in hand.

"As malignant primary bone tumors are rare cancers, and as management is complex, the accepted standard is to provide access to the full spectrum of care. The cancer treatment centers, the therapy is usually given within the framework of prospective, often collaborative, clinical studies, or established treatment protocols.

An initial chemotherapy can have life-changing consequences, but unfortunately, osteosarcoma is an aggressive form of cancer, and increase in size after chemotherapy can result in limb sparing surgery or an amputation depending on the stage and spread of the cancer.”

The National Commission in its judgment dated 17/07/2017 came to the rescue of Doctors and Well known Hospital in the Country...

Case details..

BINOD CHOUDHARY & 3 ORS. V/s. #TATAMEMORIALCENTRE & 2 ORS,
CONSUMER CASE NO. 909 OF 2017
Link :
http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FCC%2F909%2F2017&dtofhearing=2017-07-17

Case of the complainant in short :

1. The deceased 25 years old patient Mr. Vishnu Raj Choudhary was diagnosed at Pune for Bone Cancer of his left leg(Tibia), in May 2014 and for further Treatment he went to Tata Memorial Center (TMC) where he consulted the opponents in this case i.e. Dr. Asish Gulia and Dr. Ajay Puri.

2. After the tests, the Doctors assured the patient that the case is 100% curable and after PET/CT, it was confirmed the case of sarcoma in the left tibia without any histopathology examination (HPE) confirmed it as distant metastasis and High-Grade Pleomorphic Osteosarcoma. The patient was advised for initial 4 sets/cycles of chemotherapy to check the progress of tumour cells and then surgery, which thereafter was to be followed by another set of chemotherapy to end the treatment.

3. A blister developed over the scene after 2nd cycle at the place of Tumor. The Dr. opined it as the side effect of Chemotherapy, but the tumor size increased, but the treatment was not changed. At 3rd cycle, CT thorax was also done and three small nodules of less than 5 mm in the lungs of the patient were revealed. The patient and the relatives requested the Doctors to remove the same, but the doctor assured them that Chemo is effective and there is no need of immediate surgery.

3. During 4th cycle, the patient was admitted in the Hospital for surgery. On the day of surgery, the Patient was asked to take bath. But according to the Complainant, there was no one from the hospital to assist the patient to go up to the Bathroom and the relatives had gone to purchase some medicines. Thus as a last resort, patient on his own with crutches reluctantly went to the bathroom, but slipped and suffered a fracture of the left tibia. Thus, according to the complainants, the patient was a victim of carelessness and negligence. It was further alleged that the patient was unattended by Sr. Doctors and Doctors had to go abroad, due to delay in the treatment of the patient developed

It was further alleged that the patient was unattended by Sr. Doctors and Doctors had to go abroad, due to delay in the treatment of the patient developed post-fracture complications, the left leg would have been saved from amputation and ultimately the patient succumbed to Death at AIIMS. The Chemo also caused complications. 5th Chemo without surgery was given just to enhance the Bill of the Hospital.

4. It was further alleged that the Doctors at AIIMS were shocked to see that why there was delay of 2 months and the fracture was a pathological fracture due to Sarcoma of bone, which never re-join.

5. The Doctors at AIIMS also continued Chemo and again 5 cycles were continued (total 11 chemos), without the surgery. The patient thereafter transferred to Medanta Hospital and lastly to Fortis Memorial hospital (where he was diagnosed as Osteosarcoma (Post Chemotherapy) , where he took his last breath. Thus, the case claiming total claim of Rs.7,36,00,000/- was filed.

Defense of Doctors :

The treatment given was as per protocol. The hospital is the reputed cancer Hospital . There was no negligence on part of Doctors.

Held :

1. The National Commission after hearing the arguments and after perusing Hospital Record and medical literature dismissed the Complaint.

2. The Commission observed that the Dr. Ajay Puri, one of the reputed oncologist started the treatment of Osteosarcoma initially with cycles of chemotherapy and thereafter planned for surgical excision. But when it was revealed @ 4th Cycle that Chemo is not getting effective results, the surgery was planned. But on the day of surgery, unfortunately, the patient suffered Fracture of left Tibia, also known as "pathological fracture" as such fractures occur during normal activity or minor trauma due to the weakening of the bone by disease and in the present case growing a malignant tumour in the left tibia. Thus the patient should have waited for someone's assistance and on the contrary, as per medical record, Drs gave necessary treatment for such fracture.

3. While negating the allegations of the Complainant regarding delay in surgery, the Commission observed as mentioned in the preface and referred hereinabove

4. It was also observed after relying upon the landmark judgments of Apex Court that there was no breach of the duty to take care and the pathological fracture and subsequent deterioration of patient’s health was due to the High Grade Osteosarcoma disease itself. Quoting
Kusum Sharma & Others vs Batra Hospital & Medical Research Centre and others, the court said

 "We must not look at the 1947 accident with 1954 spectacles". But we should be doing a disservice to the community at large if we were to impose liability on hospitals and doctors for everything that happens to go wrong. Doctors would be led to think more of their own safety than of the good of their patients. Initiative would be stifled and confidence shaken. A proper sense of  proportion requires us to have regard to the conditions in which hospitals and doctors have to work. We must insist on due care for the patient at every point, but we must not condemn as negligence that which is only a misadventure.

5. It's a landmark judgment itself in these days where cancer patients are increasing day after day. No doubt the deceased must have undergone tremendous physical and mental pain and so did his family. But as it is Said that Medical Science is an incomplete science, it has its limitations and we have to accept that.

At the same time we have to keep in mind that Drs would feel insecure to even hold a scalpel if CPA is used as a halter round the neck... Yet again proper procedure, documentation saved Drs..

Thanks & Regds,

Adv. Rohit Erande.
Pune. ©

http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FCC%2F909%2F2017&dtofhearing=2017-07-17
Meghna A Singhania
Meghna A Singhania

Meghna A Singhania is the founder and Editor-in-Chief at Medical Dialogues. An Economics graduate from Delhi University and a post graduate from London School of Economics and Political Science, her key research interest lies in health economics, and policy making in health and medical sector in the country. She is a member of the Association of Healthcare Journalists. She can be contacted at meghna@medicaldialogues.in. Contact no. 011-43720751

Show Full Article
Next Story

Editorial

Aspirin Use in Male Smokers Aged 40-45 Years with Hypertension: Identifying the Ideal Candidates

Aspirin Use in Male Smokers Aged 40-45 Years with Hypertension: Identifying the Ideal Candidates

National Consensus 2025 on Role of Bisoprolol Across CV Continuum in Women: Top 10 Takeaways

National Consensus 2025 on Role of Bisoprolol Across CV Continuum in Women: Top 10 Takeaways

Relevance of Pioglitazone in Indian T2DM Care Continuum

Relevance of Pioglitazone in Indian T2DM Care Continuum

Azmarda Outperforms Generic Sacubitril/Valsartan in HFrEF Management, says new study

Azmarda Outperforms Generic Sacubitril/Valsartan in HFrEF Management, says new study

First Indian Consensus on Managing Refractory Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Recommends Vonoprazan

First Indian Consensus on Managing Refractory Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Recommends Vonoprazan

View All

Journal Club Today

New Nasal Deformity Classification System May Enhance Standardization in Cleft Lip and Palate Assessment: Research Shows

New Nasal Deformity Classification System May Enhance Standardization in Cleft Lip and Palate...

View All

Health News Today

Health Bulletin 03/June/2025

Health Bulletin 03/June/2025

View All
© 2022 All Rights Reserved.
Powered By: Hocalwire
X
We use cookies for analytics, advertising and to improve our site. You agree to our use of cookies by continuing to use our site. To know more, see our Cookie Policy and Cookie Settings.Ok