This site is intended for Healthcare professionals only.

Delhi: AIIMS fined Rs One lakh for negligent eye treatment

Delhi: AIIMS fined Rs One lakh for negligent eye treatment

New Delhi: The premier health institute, AIIMS, has been directed to pay Rs one lakh by a consumer forum in Delhi to the parents of a girl child for alleged negligence in carrying out transplantation of cornea in her eye.

South Delhi District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum bench presided by Justice N K Goel asked the hospital to pay the money to the parents of Haryana resident Baby Priyanka, noting that three corneal graftings (surgery for cornea transplantation) in her left eye failed consecutively as they were done “without proper care and caution”.

“The three consecutive failures of corneal graftings in the left eye of the patient by the doctors of the hospital (AIIMS) establishes that corneal graftings were not done with proper care and caution as was expected from medical experts and certainly failure was the result of negligence on the part of doctors in doing the corneal graftings,” the forum said.

 “Therefore, we hold the Opposite Parties (AIIMS and its doctors) guilty of deficiency in service,” it said, directing AIIMS to pay Rs one lakh compensation to victim’s parents.

It also noted that “there is every reason to believe that corneal grafting on all the three occasions in the left eye of the girl was done by the junior/trainee/new doctors and the grafting failed on all three occasions and, therefore, she was advised to undergo fourth corneal grafting in June 2005.”

According to the complaint, the girl had suffered injury in her left eye with a knife and was operated by a doctor at Patiala in April 1998.

However, when she did not get any relief, she was taken to AIIMS for treatment in October 1998 and the three corneal graftings were done in her injured eye on different dates between 1998 and 2001, it said.

It said that post that treatment the girl lost sight in her left eye and, thereafter, she was advised for fourth corneal grafting in June 2005 at AIIMS, it added.

The complaint added that three corneal graftings were performed in girl’s left eye by the Junior/trainee/new doctors without there being any senior doctor and the junior/trainees/ new doctors did the treatment for their practical/learning purposes.

It was also alleged that few broken sutures (stitches) were found in the left eye of the girl which caused her immense pain for around four years.

AIIMS, however, had denied the allegations levelled against it.

Source: PTI
14 comment(s) on Delhi: AIIMS fined Rs One lakh for negligent eye treatment

Share your Opinion Disclaimer

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Most Voted
  1. IN INDIA patient suffers only because 1)delayed treatment 2) medical / doctors negligence.. what about child having knife in her hand and getting injured????
    anyways corneal grafting has multiple reason of failure and and repeated surgery is always a guarded prognosis.. judiciary should consider these facts before just passing a negligence judgement. there has to be some protocol

  2. user
    Dr Vishal kishore June 22, 2016, 4:43 pm

    Shame on the decisions of such intellectuals who hardly take pains to find out the so many causes of graft failure and blames everything on the doctors…easiest target of everyone…moreover it should be known to the creamy intellectuals that in a teaching institute Pgs and trainee are given such cases only when the prognosis of the eye is poor so that no harm is done to patients and it is done under senior supervision…black day for Pgs,trainee and doctors

  3. Good example for higher court to sack the judge for such a gross negligence , arrogance ,decision on personal belief not on any evidence of negligence and going beyond the limit of laws…. what negligence has occurred ? Only patient is not benefited,

  4. user
    Dr Narpat Solanki June 21, 2016, 10:55 pm

    Ridiculous. Now time has come for file defamation suit against complaintant and if higher court reverse judgment then lower court should compensate the losses because of his judgment. It only leads a moral pressure on them that what happened to other when some body is punished for no fault.

  5. user
    Dr.virendra kumarpal June 21, 2016, 10:25 pm

    in my opinion judges are not eligible person to give decision on this matter.think if judges have different opinion or different decision on same matter on human written law how they expect that how the things will be always right on god made body.such type matters will be solved by a group of doctors a special courts not by judges whose decision vary on human written law