This site is intended for Healthcare professionals only.

Maharashtra: Human Rights Commission fines govt for medical negligence

Thane: In a case of alleged medical negligence, State Human Rights Commission, has slapped the state government with compensation, while also directing to initiate action against doctors working at Civil Hospital in Thane.

The state government has been ordered to initiate action against Gynaecologists Dr Anuradha Nandpurkar, Dr S Shinde and Dr Nagarkar, by the state Human rights commission,while also being directed to pay a compensation of Rs 5-lakh  with 12% interest per annum from the time of filing the complaint, to a couple from Bhiwandi who lost their baby during delivery at the Thane Civil Hospital.

While the incident goes back to the year 2008, the state human rights commission has now asked the Maharashtra government to initiate disciplinary action against three doctors for being negligent. One of the practitioners has left the country reports Mumbai Mirror.

Haresh and Preeti Patil had filed a complaint with the police stating that Preeti went into labour on April 30, 2008, and was admitted to the Thane Civil Hospital where she would undergo a Caesarean section as advised by Dr Nandpurkar. The complainants alleged that the patient needed immediate medical attention but instead was left unattended for the next four hours as the doctor allegedly went off to attend to patients at her private clinic.

“In the meantime, the baby got stuck during labour and choked to death. Nandapurkar rushed back to the hospital but it was too late. My wife is fortunate to have survived the ordeal,” Haresh Patil said in his complaint.

With the assistance of NGO called Madat,  the couple filed a case in the matter before the state human rights commission. “The case dragged on as there was nobody to head the commission for some time. The hearing restarted only two years ago,” said Shashi Agarwal from the NGO.

The commission has also made several recommendations, such as training staff at government and civic-run hospitals to handle such emergencies and filling up vacant posts.

Source: with inputs
3 comment(s) on Maharashtra: Human Rights Commission fines govt for medical negligence

Share your Opinion Disclaimer

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Most Voted
  1. Nonsense judge of human right

  2. user
    Dr.Hindole Santosh Sadashiv November 26, 2016, 7:48 am

    State Human Rights Commission Should also work for Human Rights of Doctors also. 24/7 duty pattern is Illegal. Govt.should give time for rest, Time for personal work, Time for Family work, Time for entertainment in every 24 hrs after completion of duty hrs in a day. To make Doctors to work 24/7 without implementing 3 shifts manpower is violation of Human Rights of Doctors in govt.service. Human Rights Commision should work on this also.

  3. respondent superior
    It is case of consumer redressal
    Employee has to compensation